Cheeses

45 Products

We offer a wide selection of award-winning cheeses from the U.S. and Europe. All our cheeses are carefully chosen for their fine quality, character and flavor. Additionally, nearly all are multiple award winning from prestigious organizations like the American Cheese Society, SOFI, World Cheese Competition and countless regional awards.

We cut-to-order any size, in half pound increments, triple wrap for extra protection and ship promptly in specially designed packaging.

Carmody Cheese

$9.50$18.99

quick view Select options

Snowdonia Red Storm Leicester

$11.65

quick view Select options

Snowdonia Ginger Spice Cheddar

$11.65

quick view Read More

Apricot White Stilton

$9.99$39.96

quick view Select options

Favorite American Cheese Basket

$54.90

quick view Add to cart

Point Reyes Bay Blue Cheese

$11.95$23.90

quick view Select options

SarVecchio Parmesan Cheese

$7.50

quick view Add to cart

Bellwether Pepato All Sheep Milk Cheese

$19.95$39.95

quick view Select options

Swiss Raclette

$13.95$27.90

quick view Select options

Rogue Creamery Oregonzola

$14.99$29.95

quick view Select options

Point Reyes Toma

$10.99$21.99

quick view Select options

Blue Stilton Cheese, U.K.

$8.99$17.99

quick view Select options

Taste of Britain

$47.95$72.95

quick view Select options

Mango and Ginger White Stilton

$9.99$19.99

quick view Select options

White Stilton with Cranberries

$7.25

quick view Select options

Huntsman-Gloucester & Stilton

$9.50$18.99

quick view Select options

Cotswold-Double Gloucester w/Chive & Onion

$10.50$20.99

quick view Select options

Hook’s EWE CALF to be KIDding

$13.50$26.98

quick view Select options

Comte 12 Month Aged

$13.95$27.99

quick view Select options

Cypress Grove Midnight Moon Gouda Cheese

$12.99$25.99

quick view Select options

Cypress Grove Humboldt Fog Goat Cheese

$14.99$29.99

quick view Select options

Cabot’s Clothbound Cheddar

$13.90$27.80

quick view Select options

Cypress Grove Ms. Natural Chevre

$7.45

quick view Select options

Beehive SeaHive Cheese

$8.55

quick view Select options

Snowdonia Green Thunder Cheddar

$11.65

quick view Select options

Beehive Barely Buzzed Cheese

$8.55

quick view Select options

Fresh Soft Cheese -Cheesemaking kit

Just go for it and make your own fresh cheeseThis puts a whole new meaning to “fresh” cheese – With the Home Cheese Maker set for fresh cheese, you can make your own cheese from now on.  You can make at least 2 different kinds of fresh cheese with this Home Cheese Maker set: one for spreading, and one for cutting.Cow’s, sheep’s, or goat’s milk: whatever is your pleasure, they’re all possible.  There are clear preparation instructions and tips for varieties you will choose for cheese. Provided are all the necessary ingredients, but you can also add your own fresh herbs or dried tomatoes.A spreading knife is included as an extra. The fresh cheese conveniently stays fresh for 10 days from the fridge, if it even lasts that long. Because once you taste it, you keep on eating it. This is so tasty!You can use this Home Cheese Maker set at least 15 times. And the jar even has more uses. You can use it, for example, to grow or keep fresh herbs.Tip: Making fresh cheese is lots of fun, but take your time doing it. Read the instructions carefully first, and then have a go.Another tip:  Use the freshest milk you can find for best resultsWhat comes in the jar?-       preparation instructions/recipe-       cheesecloth-       spreading knife-       thermometer-       4 cheese molds-       2 rennet tablets-       wooden spoon-       15 gr. Provencal herbs-       50 gr. saltWhat more will you need?For fresh spreadable cheese:-       2 liters (67.6 fl. oz.) of fresh whole milk or organic milk-       20 ml (0.7 fl. oz.p) buttermilk-       kitchen utensilsPreparation time: 30 minutesReady to eat in: 20 hoursFor cuttable fresh cheese:-       2 liters (67.6 fl. oz) of fresh whole milk or organic milk-       40 ml (1.4 fl. oz) buttermilkPreparation time: 45 minutesReady to eat in: 5 hours

Fresh Soft Cheese -Cheesemaking kit

$29.99

quick view Add to cart

Mozzarella Cheesemaking Kit

$29.99

quick view Add to cart

Beecher’s Marco Polo Peppered Cheddar

$9.98

quick view Select options

Snowdonia Little Black Bomber Cheddar

$11.65

quick view Select options

Beecher’s Flagship Cheddar

$10.95

quick view Add to cart

Sgt. Pepper Chevre

$7.50

quick view Add to cart

Point Reyes Original Blue Wedges

$11.50

quick view Add to cart

BeeChive Cheese

$8.55

quick view Select options

Reserve Cheddar

$6.75

quick view Add to cart

Beehive Big John’s Cajun

$8.55

quick view Select options

Snowdonia Beechwood Cheddar

$11.65

quick view Select options

Grafton 1 Year Aged Cheddar

$8.75

quick view Add to cart

Vermont Creamery Bijou Goat Cheese

$12.95

quick view Add to cart

Cypress Grove Herbs de Humboldt Chevre

$7.45

quick view Select options

Cypress Grove Purple Haze Chevre

$7.45

quick view Select options

Cypress Grove PsycheDillic Chevre

$7.45

quick view Add to cart

Grana Padano Parmesan-Style Cheese

$16.99

quick view Select options

Vermont Creamery Cremont

$12.65

quick view Select options

Cabot Cheddar Cheese Powder

$7.95

quick view Add to cart